
A parent would reach for this book when their teenager is grappling with the complexity of global injustice, the pain of forced isolation, or the feeling of being viewed as an enemy in their own home. It is a profound choice for a child who feels like an outsider and needs to see that connection and hope can exist even in the darkest chapters of history. The story follows Alex, a Japanese American boy, and Charlie, a French Jewish girl, as they exchange letters across oceans during World War II. It masterfully weaves together the horrors of the American internment camps and the Holocaust through the lens of a deep, soul-sustaining friendship. While the subject matter is intense, it is appropriate for mature middle schoolers and high school students who are ready to discuss systemic racism and the resilience of the human spirit. Parents might choose it to help their child navigate big questions about loyalty, identity, and the courage required to remain kind in a cruel world.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewGraphic descriptions of WWII combat, injuries, and the horrors of concentration camps.
Multiple significant characters, including family and friends, die during the war.
Themes of loss, grief, and the weight of historical trauma are pervasive.
The book deals directly and unflinchingly with racism, state-sponsored violence, and mass death. It addresses the Holocaust and the American internment of Japanese citizens with historical accuracy. The approach is secular but deeply philosophical, ending on a realistic but poignant note that emphasizes the endurance of love over easy happy endings.
A high schooler who feels isolated by their identity or current political climate and is looking for a story that validates their anger at injustice while offering a path toward emotional survival.
Parents should be prepared for graphic descriptions of combat and the dehumanizing conditions of the camps. Review the chapters involving the liberation of concentration camps, as these are particularly visceral. A parent might see their child expressing profound cynicism about the world or feeling like they don't belong in their own country due to their heritage.
Younger teens will focus on the 'star-crossed' friendship and the adventure elements, while older teens will better grasp the systemic parallels between the American and European theaters of the war.
Unlike many WWII novels that focus on one perspective, this book uniquely bridges the Japanese American experience and the European Holocaust, showing the interconnectedness of global prejudice and human resilience.
Alex Maki is a Japanese American boy living in Washington who begins writing to Charlie, a French Jewish girl, for a school project. As the 1940s unfold, their worlds collapse: Alex is sent to an internment camp in California and eventually joins the 442nd Regimental Combat Team, while Charlie faces the mounting terrors of Nazi-occupied France. Their correspondence is the thread that keeps them grounded as they navigate systemic hatred and the physical brutality of war.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.