
When your child is trying their best to be kind but is met with meanness, this book validates their frustration. It follows Emma, a young witch, who resolves to be nicer to two mean-spirited older witches, Dolores and Lavinia. Despite her best efforts, they continue to torment her, pushing her patience to its limit. The story explores the difficult emotions of anger and fairness, culminating in a humorous and satisfying magical revenge. For ages 4-7, it's a perfect choice for opening a conversation about why 'being the bigger person' is hard and acknowledging the very real temptation to get even, all within a safe, fantastical context.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewThe book deals directly with bullying. The approach is not one of reconciliation or understanding the bully's perspective. Instead, it validates the victim's anger and frustration. The resolution is based on cathartic, comical revenge rather than forgiveness. This is presented in a completely secular and fantastical context, with the revenge being magical and harmless, leading to a humorous and triumphant ending for the protagonist.
A 5 to 7-year-old who is struggling with a one-sided friendship or a mild bullying situation. This child feels like their efforts to 'be the bigger person' or 'use their words' are failing, and they are getting fed up. The book is for the child who needs their feelings of anger and injustice validated in a safe, funny way.
A parent should be prepared to discuss the ending. While the revenge is funny in a story, it's a good opportunity to talk about fantasy versus real-life solutions to conflict. A parent might ask, "What would be a good real-life way to handle this?" No major prep is needed to read it cold, but a post-reading conversation is highly recommended to contextualize the theme of revenge. The parent has just heard their child say, "I tried to be nice, but they're still so mean to me! It's not fair! I just want to be mean back!" The child is at the breaking point of their patience and sense of fairness.
A younger child (4-5) will focus on the slapstick humor of the pranks and the silly, imaginative revenge. An older child (6-7) will better understand Emma's internal conflict, the struggle between her goal and her feelings, and the concept of justice. They will more deeply connect with the feeling of being pushed too far.
Unlike many books about bullying that advocate for empathy and turning the other cheek, this story uniquely validates a child's desire for payback. By making the revenge fantastical and comical (not physically harmful), it offers a safe catharsis for feelings of helplessness and anger, acknowledging that sometimes being good is incredibly hard and doesn't immediately solve the problem.
Young witch Emma makes a New Year's resolution to be nicer to the perpetually dreadful older witches, Dolores and Lavinia. They test her resolve with a series of mean-spirited pranks, like tripping her and putting a frog in her bed. Emma's frustration builds until she finally breaks her resolution on New Year's Day, enacting a clever and satisfying magical revenge by turning their house into a giant, melting ice cream cone.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.