
Reach for this book when your teenager is struggling with the emotional fallout of a family crisis, particularly when a sibling is facing a long term medical emergency or a coma. It is a sensitive choice for families navigating the guilt and confusion that follow a sudden accident, providing a safe space to process the 'what ifs' that often haunt siblings left in the wake of tragedy. The story follows fifteen year old Hal as he vacations at the beach where his sister, Charley, had a life altering accident the year before. Through a blend of realistic family drama and a supernatural connection, Hal begins to hear Charley's thoughts and piece together the truth of that day. This book addresses profound themes of grief, the weight of family secrets, and the difficult process of moving forward. It is most appropriate for mature readers aged 12 and up due to its heavy emotional content and the intense depiction of a family in various stages of breakdown and healing.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewAtmospheric, haunting sequences where Hal hears his sister's voice.
Descriptions of a life threatening drowning accident and risky swimming.
Characters keep secrets about the accident out of fear and guilt.
The book deals intensely with traumatic brain injury and the 'limbo' of a persistent vegetative state. The approach is secular and deeply psychological. While there is a supernatural element (telepathy), the resolution is emotionally realistic: it focuses on acceptance and truth rather than a miraculous recovery.
A thoughtful, sensitive teenager who feels invisible within their own family drama. This is for the 'well sibling' who is tired of being brave and needs to see their own anger and confusion reflected on the page.
Parents should be aware of a brief, intense scene involving a near-drowning and the descriptions of Charley's physical state in the hospital. The book can be read cold by most teens, but a check-in regarding the depiction of parental neglect due to grief might be helpful. A parent might see their child withdrawing or expressing irrational guilt after a family tragedy. They might hear their child say, 'Everything is different now,' or witness them struggling to connect with a sibling who has changed due to illness.
Younger teens will focus on the mystery and the 'ghost story' aspect. Older teens will resonate more with the complex dynamics of Hal's crumbling relationship with his parents and the nuances of his blooming first romance.
Dogar uses the supernatural element not as a gimmick, but as a metaphor for the intuitive, unspoken bonds between siblings. It captures the 'sensory' experience of grief better than almost any other YA novel on the subject.
One year after a tragic accident left his sister Charley in a coma, Hal and his parents return to the same Cornish seaside town. While his parents are drowning in their own grief and denial, Hal begins to experience a sensory, psychic connection with Charley. He 'hears' her memories and feelings, which leads him to investigate the suspicious circumstances of her accident and the mysterious boy she was with.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.