
Reach for this book when your teenager is grappling with questions of justice, the impact of rumors, or the weight of being perceived as different within a tight-knit community. Through a multi-perspective narrative, the story explores the aftermath of a violent hate crime targeting an HIV-positive student, drawing in the accused and a witness with Down syndrome. It is a powerful tool for discussing prejudice and the moral courage required to tell the truth. Parents will appreciate its nuanced look at chronic illness and neurodivergence, though it deals with mature themes suited for high schoolers. It is an excellent choice for fostering deep empathy and discussing how fear can divide a community.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewThemes of chronic illness, isolation, and the fear of mortality.
Realistic high school dialogue including some swearing and slurs used by antagonists.
The book addresses HIV/AIDS stigma, hate crimes, and neurodivergence directly and realistically. The approach is secular and focuses on the sociological and legal consequences of bias. The resolution is realistic and somewhat hopeful, prioritizing truth over easy forgiveness.
A thoughtful high schooler who enjoys social thrillers or stories about systemic injustice. It is particularly resonant for teens who feel like outsiders or those interested in how different people perceive the same event.
Parents should be prepared for the depiction of a violent assault and the use of derogatory language by certain characters to illustrate their prejudice. The book should be read with the context of late 90s/early 2000s social attitudes toward HIV. A parent might see their child being unfairly stereotyped at school, or perhaps their child is struggling to stand up for a friend who is being bullied for being different.
Younger teens (14) will focus on the mystery of who did it and the social dynamics of the school. Older teens (17-18) will better grasp the complexities of the legal system and the systemic nature of the prejudice depicted.
Flinn uses a unique three-way perspective that includes a character with Down syndrome, providing a rare and respectful look at neurodivergent processing and morality in a high-stakes situation.
The story unfolds through three alternating voices: Alex, a teenager living with HIV who is hospitalized after a concrete block is thrown through his car window; Clinton, the school athlete and suspected bigot accused of the crime; and Darrin, a student with Down syndrome who witnessed the event but struggles to communicate what he saw. The narrative follows the legal and social fallout as the community reacts with fear and prejudice.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.