
Reach for this book when your child is struggling with school-based competition or feels their status as the top student is being threatened by a newcomer. This relatable story follows a high-achieving girl who has always been the teacher's favorite until a new boy arrives and matches her every accomplishment. It masterfully explores the uncomfortable feelings of jealousy, the pressure of perfectionism, and the shift from rivalry to genuine friendship. Ideal for ages 7 to 10, it provides a safe space to discuss how our identity is more than just our grades or our standing in the classroom. Parents will appreciate how it validates the sting of comparison while modeling a path toward empathy and collaboration.
The book deals with social status and academic pressure. The approach is direct and secular, focusing on the internal emotional landscape of a child. The resolution is realistic and hopeful, emphasizing personal growth over winning.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewA high-achieving 8-year-old who is prone to perfectionism or who has recently expressed frustration because a peer received praise they felt they deserved.
This is a safe read-cold book. No specific scenes require previewing, but parents should be ready to talk about the concept of 'the teacher's pet' and whether that's a label their child identifies with. A child coming home and complaining that a specific classmate is 'annoying' or 'trying too hard,' or a child who becomes tearful over a single B grade or a missed gold star.
Younger readers (7-8) will focus on the funny classroom antics and the 'fairness' of the teacher's attention. Older readers (9-10) will pick up on the nuanced social dynamics and the stress of maintaining a certain reputation.
Unlike many school stories that focus on bullies, Clements focuses on the 'good kids' and the unique pressures and jealousies that exist within that high-achieving demographic.
The story centers on Natalie Adams, a third-grader who takes great pride in being the model student and the clear favorite of her teacher, Mrs. Higgins. Her world is shaken when a new student, Gavin, arrives. Gavin is just as smart, helpful, and eager to please as Natalie. The narrative follows their escalating rivalry as Natalie tries to reclaim her 'throne,' leading to moments of social friction and internal crisis before they eventually realize they have more in common than they thought.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.