
Reach for this book when your teen is navigating the complex weight of family expectations versus their own personal truth. It is a powerful choice for families dealing with the fallout of inherited grudges or the unique emotional burden of having an incarcerated parent. The story follows Kaitlin Malone, who falls for the son of the man her father was convicted of killing, forcing her to confront a web of lies and long-held family secrets. Through Kaitlin's journey, the book explores profound themes of honesty, the nuances of justice, and the courage it takes to forgive. It is a sophisticated, emotionally resonant read for older middle schoolers and high school students that helps normalize feelings of shame and isolation while opening doors for conversations about seeing both sides of a story.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewThemes of grief, family loss, and the pain of a parent being in prison.
The protagonist lies about her identity for a significant portion of the book.
Discussion of a past fatal altercation between the families.
The book deals directly with the impact of a parent's incarceration and the death of a community member. The approach is realistic and secular, focusing on the psychological toll of these events rather than legal or religious frameworks. The resolution is hopeful but grounded in the reality that healing takes significant work.
A high schooler who feels defined by their family's reputation or mistakes and is struggling to forge an independent identity. It is perfect for the teen who enjoys lyrical writing and emotional depth.
Read cold. Parents may want to discuss the legal distinction between the different types of homicide mentioned to help contextulize the father's actions. A parent might notice their child withdrawing from family traditions or expressing frustration about 'old' stories and grudges that no longer seem relevant to the teen's world.
Younger teens (13-14) will focus on the 'star-crossed' romance and the tension of the secret. Older teens (16+) will likely resonate more with the themes of breaking generational cycles and the complexity of moral gray areas.
Unlike many YA romances, the 'enemy' family isn't a caricature: the book treats the pain on both sides with equal gravity and focuses heavily on the protagonist's internal growth through her journals.
Kaitlin Malone has been raised on a steady diet of hatred for the Crutchfield family. When her father is sent to prison for the death of a Crutchfield, she expects to carry that torch of resentment forever. However, a chance meeting with Bram Crutchfield changes everything. To explore her feelings without the weight of their names, she hides her identity, creating a precarious foundation for their relationship. As she gets closer to Bram, she discovers that her family's version of the truth is only one piece of a much larger, darker puzzle.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.