
Reach for this book when your child feels frustrated by a parent's high standards or is struggling to find their own voice within a strict family environment. Set in the 1960s, it follows Abby Lovitt, a girl living on a California horse ranch where her father trains horses with a firm, often unyielding hand. Abby must navigate the physical demands of farm life while processing her father's demanding expectations and the emotional toll of seeing the horses she loves being sold away. This is a deeply grounded story about resilience, the ethics of how we treat animals, and the quiet courage required to grow up. It explores the tension between duty and desire, making it an excellent choice for middle-grade readers who are beginning to question authority or seeking a more mature, realistic look at the bond between humans and animals. Jane Smiley's prose is sophisticated yet accessible, offering a mirrors-and-windows experience for any child learning to balance their internal world with external pressures.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewThe emotional weight of horses being sold and the protagonist's feelings of isolation.
The book handles religious themes (fundamentalist Christianity) and parental discipline in a direct, realistic manner. The father's strictness is not portrayed as abusive, but it is heavy and sometimes emotionally distant. The resolution is realistic rather than sugary: Abby gains self-assurance, but her circumstances don't radically change.
A 10-year-old girl who loves animals but is looking for something deeper than a standard 'pony book.' It is perfect for the child who feels they can never quite please a parent or who finds more peace in nature than in social circles.
Read cold. Parents may want to be ready to discuss the 1960s setting and the specific religious expectations (no movies, strict Sunday observance) that might seem alien to modern children. A parent might see their child withdrawing after a critique or notice the child seems to be 'performing' for approval rather than acting out of joy.
Younger readers (8-9) will focus on the horse training and the physical danger of being thrown. Older readers (11-12) will pick up on the subtle emotional tension between Abby and her father and the ethical questions regarding the treatment of animals.
Unlike many horse books that romanticize the bond between girl and horse, Smiley uses her expertise to show the grit, danger, and business-like reality of ranching while maintaining a high level of literary sophistication.
Abby Lovitt lives on her family's horse ranch in 1960s California. Her father is a horse trader who names every gelding George and every mare Jewel to avoid getting attached. Abby is a skilled rider but must constantly prove herself to her demanding, religiously devout father. The story follows her daily life of schooling horses, attending school, and navigating the complex morality of the horse business, where animals are treated as commodities despite the deep bonds she forms with them.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.