
Reach for this book when your teenager is struggling with a profound sense of not belonging, or when they are grieving the loss of a place or a dream that felt like home. While many stories end when the heroes return from a magical land, this novel explores the painful aftermath: how do you live in the ordinary world when your heart is elsewhere? It follows the Hapwell siblings, Evelyn, Philippa, and Jamie, who spent years in the magical kingdom of the Woodlands during WWII, only to be thrust back into post-war England. It is a deeply atmospheric exploration of mental health, sisterly bonds, and the courage it takes to choose reality when fantasy feels more real. The emotional weight is significant, making it a powerful choice for older teens navigating depression, identity crises, or the difficult transition into adulthood. It validates the feeling that sometimes the world is just too much, while gently pointing toward the possibility of healing.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewCharacters make difficult choices between fantasy and reality that may be polarizing.
War-time imagery (London Blitz) and some peril within the magical realm.
Themes of self-harm and characters being in physical danger due to their emotional state.
The book deals heavily with depression, self-harm, and eating disorders. These are handled with a mix of metaphorical resonance (the 'ache' for another world) and stark realism. The approach is secular and psychological. The resolution is bittersweet and realistic rather than a magical fix, emphasizing that recovery is a slow process.
A high schooler who feels like an outsider or is struggling with 'post-adventure' blues, such as finishing a beloved series or returning from a life-changing experience, and needs a story that acknowledges their internal sadness.
Parents should be aware of scenes involving self-harm and the protagonist's struggle with an eating disorder. The book can be read cold by mature teens, but conversation around mental health resources is advised. A parent might notice their child withdrawing, expressing that they feel they 'don't belong' in their current life, or showing signs of escapism through media or fantasy.
Younger teens (14) will likely focus on the fantasy elements and the sibling rivalry, while older teens (17-18) will better grasp the sophisticated metaphors for trauma and the difficulty of transitioning to adulthood.
Unlike Narnia, which focuses on the wonder of the other world, this book focuses on the trauma of leaving it. It is a unique 'reverse portal fantasy' that prioritizes psychological depth over magical world-building.
The story follows Evelyn Hapwell and her siblings, who were transported to a magical realm called the Woodlands during the London Blitz. Years later, they are returned to England, but Evelyn cannot reconcile her life in 1940s London with the queen she was in the Woodlands. As Evelyn's mental health declines, her sister Philippa desperately tries to keep her grounded in the real world. The narrative shifts between the siblings' perspectives and time periods, detailing their time in the Woodlands and the fallout of their return.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.